Carolingian History and the Historians’ Metanarrative




Construtivismo, Contingência, Cultura histórica


The essence of historian’s craft or his or her ability to construct narratives where only bits of information had reached him or her by way of written or oral tradition is one of the main problems of investigation in the discipline of history. Historians of the Carolingian age present a particularly difficult task for researchers because their work joined in one narrative both their own attitudes and judgments and the attempts to construct a pro-Carolingian, universal and thus non-partisan historical outlook. Looking to the past, Carolingian historians balanced on the verge between providing a contemporary account of recent events, the narrative being shaped in favor of ruling kings, their patrons, and the need to look deeper into the past in search of forces that underlay the Carolingian success. The historical picture we use today was constructed by contemporary historians and it could not have been produced by relying only on documents. It was not a “fabrication” in the negative sense of the term, but a “construction” in the positive meaning. Thus, key episodes of Charlemagne’s reign could not be understood without the Carolingian historians’ “authorial license”. Only the historical narrative construed a meaningful sequence of events that could be reproduced in the memory. But at the same time, once we approach these key events, we are left with historians’ interpretations rather than facts. Thus, the Carolingian period in the history of the Frankish kingdom, and particularly the reign of Charlemagne, can be seen as a constructed narrative, which cannot be perceived without looking at the context of its origin and the authors’ “creative” influence on the representation of the past.


Não há dados estatísticos.

Biografia do Autor

Dmitri Starostin, University of St-Petersburg, Department of History, St-Petersburg, Russian Federation

Lecturer, Department of History



Como Citar

STAROSTIN, D. Carolingian History and the Historians’ Metanarrative. História da Historiografia: International Journal of Theory and History of Historiography, Ouro Preto, v. 11, n. 26, 2018. DOI: 10.15848/hh.v0i26.1112. Disponível em: Acesso em: 27 out. 2021.